Guest Comments
"We had a wonderful experience! Your staff was so wonderful, front desk people were the best I've ever dealt with, Ever! Will be back" - Sarah & Pete M. Jonesboro, AR
"My family and I have enjoyed our stay here for 3 years in a row! All of the staff members are great!" - Brian T. Hemet, CA.
"We've driven past your hotel for years on our way to another Shelter Island Hotel and decided to try your hotel. We were immediately impressed with the friendless and professionalism of your staff. We'll start staying at the Bay Club Hotel several times a year instead of the other hotels on Shelter Island." - Blas & Julie R., Tucson, AZ
"Nice, homey comfortable atmosphere with staff who care. Room, front desk and restaurant staff were great! Great Chef!!" - R. Shelly, Phoenix, AZ
"We had been staying at another hotel on Shelter Island and decided to try the Bay Club. Loved the free breakfast, will be back next time. Staff very helpful and friendly" - Doris A. Las Vegas NV
"This hotel was fantastic and such a lovely end to our holiday, but I must say that 4 days were not enough. We couldn't believe how spacious the room was with a balcony and lovely view. The food is out of this world with a variety to suit everyone, my compliments go to the Chef. The staff are very friendly and took the time to chat with us which made us feel more at home and relaxed and they were more than happy to help us with our needs" - Honeymoon Couple, England
"My family and I have enjoyed our stay here for 3 years in a row! All of the staff members are great!" - Brian T. Hemet, CA.
"We've driven past your hotel for years on our way to another Shelter Island Hotel and decided to try your hotel. We were immediately impressed with the friendless and professionalism of your staff. We'll start staying at the Bay Club Hotel several times a year instead of the other hotels on Shelter Island." - Blas & Julie R., Tucson, AZ
"Nice, homey comfortable atmosphere with staff who care. Room, front desk and restaurant staff were great! Great Chef!!" - R. Shelly, Phoenix, AZ
"We had been staying at another hotel on Shelter Island and decided to try the Bay Club. Loved the free breakfast, will be back next time. Staff very helpful and friendly" - Doris A. Las Vegas NV
"This hotel was fantastic and such a lovely end to our holiday, but I must say that 4 days were not enough. We couldn't believe how spacious the room was with a balcony and lovely view. The food is out of this world with a variety to suit everyone, my compliments go to the Chef. The staff are very friendly and took the time to chat with us which made us feel more at home and relaxed and they were more than happy to help us with our needs" - Honeymoon Couple, England
